42nd largest property casualty group specializing in business risks, and 6th largest flood insurer, established in 1926.

Visit: Selective Insurance Group  |  Branchville, NJ


Founded in 1864 and now employing over 30,000 employees and representing 13,000 independent agents. Our legacy began in 1912, when our founder and grandfather, Harry S. Seely, began working for them in NYC!  They have a strong appetite for both personal and business insurance.

Visit: The Travelers Companies  |  New York, NY

Founded in 1899 and located in Edmeston, NY with over 800 employees. Specializing in Personal, Auto, Home & Umbrella they are extremely dedicated to their community and clients.

Visit: New York Central Mutual Insurance  |  Edmeston, NY

Insuring automobiles (personal & business) since 1937, and also famous for writing client ‘toys’ (ATV, motorcycles, RV’s, Boats, etc).  Most everyone is familiar with Flo!

Visit: The Progressive Corporation  |  Mayfield, OH


Protecting What Matters Since 1923, Safeco® is known for helping people protect the lives they’ve built, but we’re also known for being a great place to work, nurturing community involvement and supporting independent insurance agents with innovative tools and programs.

Visit: Safeco Insurance  |  Seattle, WA


Recently merging with ACE, Chubb is well known for their expertise in coverage & claims for high value homes and autos.  They are also a premier writer of specialty business products like Executive Protection, Builders Risk, E&O, Excess liability, and more.

Visit: Chubb Limited  |  Warren Township, NJ

Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual Insurance helps people preserve and protect what they earn, build, own, and cherish. Keeping this promise means we are there when our customers need us most.  Whether you are a starting small business or managing a multinational corporation you can feel confident that we’ll protect your business.

Visit: Liberty Mutual  |  Boston, MA


Located in New York City, MetLife offers solutions and guidance to help customers meet their goals and navigate life’s twists and turns.

Visit: MetLife  |  New York, NY

Sterling Insurance

Sterling Insurance Company is located in Cobleskill, New York. Since 1895, they have been providing quality insurance protection with an ever expanding array of product offerings. Today, they insure over 100,000 New Yorkers.

Visit: Sterling Insurance  |  Cobleskill, NY


Founded in 1852 and based in Worcester, MA with a 160 year history, they write property casualty for businesses and individuals.  Named a top 50 most Trustworthy financial firms in the U.S. by Forbes.

Visit: The Hanover Insurance Group  |  Worcester, MA

A regional carrier for personal and business insurance started in 1896 writing business in NY, NJ, MA, & NH.  They’ve been recognized for their steady growth & profitability and great customer service.

Visit: Preferred Mutual  |  New Berlin, NY


A leading carrier for over 200 years old with strength in property casualty and employee benefits, and JD Powers has recognized them for delivering outstanding service.

Visit: The Hartford Financial Services Group  |  Hartford, CT

A top 100 insurance carrier in the nation, selling personal & business products, as well as specializing in many niche business segments.

Visit: Utica National Insurance Group  |  Utica, NY

Utica First Insurance Company was founded by local Utica, New York businessmen in 1903.  We actively write business in the states of New York, Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Jersey, Maryland, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Virginia.  Its product line has expanded to include Homeowners, Landlord Package, Restaurant and Tavern Program, Convenience Store Program, Artisan Contractor Policies and Business owner Policies

Visit: Utica First Insurance Company  |  Oriskany NY

Main Street America Group

Selling personal and business insurance through 3000 independent agents nationwide in 36 states since 1932.

Visit: The Main Street America Group  |  Jacksonville, FL

Since we first opened our doors in 1962, we’ve provided comprehensive coverage options ranging from personal auto insurance to homeowners insurance to mechanical breakdown protection.  With Mercury, we believe in having the best of both worlds. Low rates, excellent coverage and a local agent who’s there every step of the way.

Visit: Mercury Insurance  |  Los Angeles, CA

Philadelphia Insurance

Specializes in designing and underwriting more unique commercial risks, including professional liability, with over 50 offices while maintaining an A++ rating with AM Best.

Visit: Philadelphia Insurance Companies  |  Bala Cynwyd, PA

Offering home & auto policies in all 50 states via 20,000 independent agents, and they also provide a convenient all in one personal package policy.

Visit: Kemper Corporation  |  Chicago, IL


A member of the Farmers Insurance Group specializing in Dwelling Fire, motorcycles, RV & Boat insurance.  They started in 1952 targeting mobile homes.

Visit: Foremost Insurance Group  |  Caledonia, MI

60 years experience with auto & RV insurance, as well as motorcycle and commercial vehicles.

Visit: National General Insurance  |  Winston-Salem, NC

Started in 1897, specializing in home, auto, & umbrella coverage all packaged in one policy and sold exclusively via Independent Insurance agents.

Visit: Encompass Insurance Company  |  Northbrook, IL

Ontario Insurance Company

Established on June 12, 1877, Ontario Insurance Co is represented in over 130 independent agency locations in New York State.

Visit: Ontario Insurance Company  |  Shortsville, NY

Dryden Mutual

Dryden Mutual uses nearly 300 independent insurance agency locations across the state of New York.

Visit: Dryden Mutual Insurance Company  |  Dryden, NY

Personal Umbrella offers standalone umbrella policies in 45 states, including New York, New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, and Connecticut.